Is there a link to an original or default pythonanywhere wsgi file, or other way I can view the differences?... I could possibly create a new web app and get it from there then delete the web app. I could git add /path/to/wsgi in the future, which I have a hunch is probably not a good idea. I re-learned from reading forum posts prior to this to use the logs to debug problems.
EDIT: It helped to step away from the project for a while and think about it. I just created a new app, a very easy process, this fixed my problem.